Monday, September 7, 2009

All the Shah's Men

All the Shah’s Men, by Stephen Kinzer, relates the story of the American coup in Iran in 1953. A significant portion of the book is devoted to describing Iran’s history, culture, and religion, written in a fascinating, almost novel-like fashion. It explains how Muslims invaded the Iran plateau and subjugated the Persian people, imposing their laws and religion.

After describing the ancient history of Iran, Kinzer goes on to discuss its relations with Britain, focusing mainly on the oil company. The Shahs in Iran were obsessed with personal wealth, and often sold whole industries to other countries, mainly Britain. One of these industries was the oil industry, which turned out to be extremely productive for the British. As the Shahs gained wealth and lost natural resources, Iran was making slow but steady progress towards democracy. By WWII, the people had forced the Shah into accepting a parliament and a prime minister. Mohammad Mossadegh was the first progressive, open-minded prime minister, and one of the most popular figures in Iran. He nationalized the oil industry, taking it away from the Anglo Persian Oil Company. After losing the case in Belgium’s International Court, they then blockaded the Persian Gulf, halting Iran’s trade and their economy. Since Mossadegh was a socialist and friendly with the Russians, the British convinced the US to assist them in a coup to depose Mossadegh and instate a more pro-Western prime minister. Unfortunately, they were successful with the help of the Shah and some military officers, and Iran lost all democratic progress.

The book attributes a lot of the problems in diplomacy between the Middle East and the United States to this singular piece of history, declaring that the United States destroyed democracy in the entire region. I really enjoyed how easy the book was to read, and found it an enjoyable though surprising and often sad story.

-Catherine of Aragon

5 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This book seems like a great book to read if one wants to find out why the relations between The Middle East and the US are so bad

    ReplyDelete
  3. My book Genghis Khan and the making of the modern world goes into depth about how the Mongols shaped the Middle East did our book talk about that at all in the beginning of it at all?
    -The omnipotent Mao Zedong

    ReplyDelete
  4. Iran has an interesting history, and it seems to be clearly illustrated in this book. Does the author discuss topics of modern history, or just of Iran's development?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great work!

    One of the most fascinating parts of this book was the way Kermit Roosevelt arranged for the BBC to use its broadcast as part of a secret transmission to the leaders of the coup.

    That just floored me.

    Do you think it was true?

    Mrs. McCabe

    ReplyDelete